Image courtesy of Scryfall.com

Grading’s Role in Fencer Clique Valuation for MTG Collectors

When you open a fresh booster from Morningtide and meet a little blue faerie with a big punch, you’re not just looking at a cute flavor text moment—you’re peeking at a piece of a much larger ecosystem: the market value that hinges on condition, rarity, and, increasingly, the stamp of professional graders. Grading companies have become the quiet referees of MTG card value, translating a card’s physical reality into a universally recognized score. For a blue common like Fencer Clique, the story is especially instructive: the card is strong for its era in terms of play design, yet its price trajectory is deeply sensitive to whether it’s in pristine condition and whether it exists in foil form. 🧙‍♂️🔥

Fencer Clique is a creature — Faerie Soldier — that wears its blue heart on its sleeve: a humble 2 mana blue mana cost of {2}{U}{U}, a respectable 3/2 body, and the quintessentially flashy Flyers ability. The card’s text, “Flying; {U}: Put this creature on top of its owner's library,” invites a playful perception of value beyond raw stats. In strategies that care about library manipulation, it’s a niche delight; for collectors, the card’s value hinges on rarity and presentation. Morningtide, released in 2008, marked an era when Wizards explored more subtheme synergies and subtle nods to tempo play. As a common, Fencer Clique typically sits in the middle-bench of MTG’s price ladder, with non-foil prices around a few dimes and foil versions a touch more—yet those numbers can swing wildly once a graded slab gets involved. 💎⚔️

What grading changes for a card like this

• Condition and centering: Grading is essentially a quality meter. For a common like Fencer Clique, tiny centering shifts, edge fraying, or corner dings can substantially affect a numeric grade. A high-precision grade like a PSA 9 or BGS 9.5 can push a card into a category of “display-worthy” rather than “play-set only.”
• Surface and print quality: Morningtide-era cards often carry subtle surface imperfections, and top-condition copies can fetch a premium when slabbed. Buyers who care about visual quality will pay for a pristine surface that looks immaculate in a display case.
• Foil vs. non-foil premium: A foil Fencer Clique is a rarity in a common slot, and if graded, the foil’s transparency and bleed must be immaculate to earn top marks. The combination of foil condition and grade can yield a notable premium versus a non-foil counterpart—especially for collectors who chase specific finishes.
• Set and variant awareness: While Morningtide is not the oldest set, graders and buyers consider the card’s print run and any known misprints. A pristine reprint or variant can carry additional premium if it appears within the same graded slab traceable to a specific lot or printing run.
• Market perception: Graded MTG cards still operate within a relatively elastic market. For common cards, the grading premium tends to be modest unless you target proofs-of-condition for showpieces, or you’re tying the card to a broader display or investment thesis. Even so, a graded Fencer Clique can stand out in a binder or display case where condition tells a story beyond the play value. 🧙‍♂️

In practical terms, if you’re evaluating the value of a Fencer Clique, you should first gauge whether you’re chasing a playable copy or a display-grade collectible. If you’re mainly after play value in a casual or semi-competitive setting, a near-mint non-foil copy in good condition will perform well enough. If you’re a grader, or you’re buying with a goal of future appreciation, a well-graded foil or near-perfect non-foil can be worth a closer look, especially given the card’s timeless blue tempo and the nostalgia factor that blue MTG enthusiasts adore. 🔥

“A well-graded card is not just a piece of cardboard; it’s a tiny time capsule that preserves the exact moment you first discovered a deck’s tempo and the thrill of a well-timed draw.”

From a collector’s standpoint, Fencer Clique sits at an interesting crossroads. It’s not a centerpiece like a powerful mythic or a coveted foil from a high-stakes set, but it has a charming, enduring personality that attracts fans of tempo and flight. Grading, then, becomes a way to elevate the narrative of your collection: demonstrating care, provenance, and an eye for condition that ages gracefully like a fine spell. 🧙‍♂️🎨

The practical path for collectors and graders

• Assess the card’s condition and consider professional grading if you have a near-mint or mint copy with flawless centering and clean edges.
• Consider foil vs. non-foil variants—foils can move the needle, but require pristine surface and edges to maximize grade.
• Compare the card’s price across platforms, noting the difference between raw copies and graded slabs to avoid overpaying for a grade that doesn’t add meaningful value in your local market. 💰
• Remember that grading is part of a broader strategy: it can protect and showcase your collection, while also signaling to other players and collectors a standard of care and curation. 🛡️
• Stay mindful of the trade-off: grading fees, turnaround times, and variety across grading companies all affect the overall ROI. A calculated approach often pays off more than rushing a submission. 🔄

More from our network

• https://crypto-acolytes.xyz/blog/post/nft-stats-nft-516-from-useless-unibots-collection/
• https://blog.crypto-articles.xyz/blog/post/nft-data-geek-3295-from-geeks-collection-on-magiceden/
• https://crypto-acolytes.xyz/blog/post/secret-lair-art-reinterpretations-of-saber-tooth-moose-lion/
• https://crypto-acolytes.xyz/blog/post/steampunk-realms-explored-open-world-games-edition/
• https://blog.rusty-articles.xyz/blog/post/control-ray-tracing-performance-review-pc-vs-console/